Prosecutors Probe an Alleged Plot to Put a Second Dan Sullivan on Alaska’s Ballot. The New York Times Says Peltola Aides and DSCC Staff Ran It.
Days before the election, a New York Times investigation alleges that aides to Democratic Senate nominee Mary Peltola and staff at the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee ran a “ballot composition project” to put a second Dan Sullivan on the Alaska ballot and siphon votes from Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan.
Peltola says she knew nothing about it. Her campaign and the DSCC deny involvement. Federal prosecutors say they are investigating “intensely and swiftly,” Gov. Mike Dunleavy has ordered a separate state probe, and no one has been charged.
Update, November 2: A federal judge dismissed the Justice Department’s lawsuit to block certification on November 1, and the department says it will appeal. The criminal probe continues. See § 05.
- 12 — sources behind the Times report, plus text messages and documents, Source: ABC News, Oct. 28, 2026
- 2 — separate government probes: a federal criminal investigation and a state inquiry ordered by Gov. Dunleavy · Source: TIME; ABC News
- 0 — people charged; the U.S. Attorney declined to say what crime is under investigation · Source: Mediaite; ABC News
The Times report, published October 28, rests on 12 sources, text messages and documents prepared for a possible lawsuit, per ABC News. It describes campaign staff, Peltola’s lawyers and senior DSCC aides working together on what they internally called the “ballot composition project,” according to Fox News and ABC.
The central source is Elisa Rios, Peltola’s former campaign manager, who was fired in August. She told the Times the effort began in summer 2025 and that a staffer was told to find as many Alaskans named Dan Sullivan as possible from the voter rolls. She said Peltola was not directly involved but was “definitely aware.” Rios later asked the Times to retract her statements without saying why; the paper kept them, citing texts, documents and 11 other sources, per Fox News and ABC.
Fox News’s summary adds that Democratic operative Jerid Kurtz allegedly used aliases to recruit candidates, that drywall contractor Gerald Heikes was allegedly recruited, and that Democrat David Leslie was allegedly pressured to drop out to clear a ballot spot. The Times also reported that ballot-stacking tactics are generally legal and used by both parties.
Peltola’s committee, Alaskans for Mary, said it “has no involvement with either Sullivan campaign.” The DSCC said it was “not involved with Dan J. Sullivan” and pointed to a 2024 episode in which the state GOP backed a Democratic House candidate in a ballot challenge against Peltola, per ABC. At a Juneau rally on October 29, Peltola said, “I knew nothing about any other candidates on the ballot except for me and the incumbent,” and, “I am not interested in tricking voters.”
Dan J. Sullivan, a retired teacher from Petersburg, appears on the ballot as “Daniel J. Sullivan Jr.” with no party affiliation, per ABC. He has said in court filings and interviews that he entered the race on his own and denied trying to confuse voters. State elections officials ruled him ineligible as a candidate filed to mislead; the Alaska Supreme Court reversed that in June, finding no basis in state law or the Constitution to remove him, per the Alaska Beacon. ABC reports courts found nothing illegal in his bid, even if it was not entirely in “good faith.”
Reports differ on his registration: Fox News says he switched to Republican shortly before filing, and ABC calls him a Republican, while the ballot lists no party.
Fox News describes him as “known to his critics as ‘Decoy Dan,’” a nickname that also appears in Washington Examiner and Daily Wire headlines. It is a characterization, not a finding: he denies being a decoy, and no court or investigator has said he was recruited.
At an Anchorage press conference on October 30, U.S. Attorney Michael Heyman (a Trump administration appointee) said the Justice Department is acting “intensely and swiftly” on “deeply troubling” new information, producing a “significant surge” of law enforcement resources, per ABC. The probe predates the Times story by several months, and a wave of subpoenas has gone out, per ABC.
“I'm not going to make any assumptions on if a crime has been committed or not.”
U.S. Attorney Michael Heyman, Oct. 30, 2026, per Mediaite
Gov. Mike Dunleavy (R) ordered a state investigation, saying the reporting showed “new evidence” of an effort to mislead voters, per TIME. The Justice Department also filed to preserve and segregate all ballots ranking Daniel J. Sullivan, per PBS NewsHour and NPR. Separately, President Trump posted that Peltola should be “removed from the Ballot and prosecuted,” and House Oversight Chair James Comer (R-KY) sent letters seeking transcribed interviews with Rios and Kurtz, per The Hill.
The legal theory is unsettled. Alaska Beacon reporting in August described investigators weighing whether two or more people conspired to create the candidacy, including wire-fraud and conspiracy-to-deprive-voters theories. Alaska attorney and former GOP operative Scott Kendall told The Hill that ballot stacking, if it happened, would be wrong but not unlawful. The state Department of Law said the Times report “confirmed its initial concerns” but that placing candidates on the ballot is a matter of state law.
A separate civil case moved fast, and a judge has since dismissed it (see § 05). The Justice Department sued on October 22 to block certification if Sen. Sullivan narrowly loses, asking that votes for Daniel J. Sullivan be counted as if cast for the incumbent. Alaska elections director Carol Beecher asked for dismissal as having no legal basis, and Judge Sharon Gleason signaled skepticism about the timing, per the Alaska Beacon. Sen. Lisa Murkowski (R-AK) said the suit should never have been filed but also demanded Peltola tell the “honest truth,” per TIME.
Mary Peltola (D) — Democratic Senate nominee. Denies knowledge; not charged.
Elisa Rios — Peltola’s former campaign manager, fired in August; the Times’s central source, who later asked to retract.
Jerid Kurtz — Democratic operative named in the Times report. Not charged.
Dan J. Sullivan — Petersburg retiree on the ballot as “Daniel J. Sullivan Jr.” Denies being recruited to spoil the race.
On Sunday, November 1, U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason (appointed by President Barack Obama, per AP) dismissed the Justice Department’s lawsuit seeking to block certification of the Senate race if the incumbent loses. She called the requested relief “infeasible” because many voters had already cast ballots, wrote that the government “provides no workable plan” to segregate votes for Dan J. Sullivan without breaching ballot secrecy, and said the bid ran against states’ constitutional authority over elections, per AP via PBS NewsHour. She also cited the Purcell principle against late changes to election rules.
The Justice Department described the dismissal as procedural and said it will appeal. A spokesperson said, “Alaskan voters deserve a fair election, not to be misled in an attempt to rig outcomes,” per AP. The ruling does not touch the criminal investigation.
That probe is widening. Federal prosecutors had issued “more than 40 grand jury subpoenas and record preservation notices” by October 28, per a CNN report citing one official, and people familiar with the investigation told CNN it is also examining possible civil rights charges, including deprivation of rights. AP reports the FBI has begun contacting Dan J. Sullivan’s donors, some of whom said agents asked whether they had been misled about which candidate they were backing. No one has been charged, and prosecutors have not said what crime they believe occurred.
On CNN’s “State of the Union,” Sen. Dan Sullivan (R-AK) said Peltola “got caught lying, and she’s still lying to the Alaskan people,” and that “there is no way this went on for a year that they weren’t informing her.” Peltola, who at a Juneau rally said she knew nothing about any other candidate, and the DSCC deny involvement. Gov. Mike Dunleavy (R) has suggested he may not certify a Peltola victory, per AP.
The Times alleges Democratic operatives deliberately fielded a second Dan Sullivan; the campaign denies it, a court has let him stay on the ballot, a federal judge has thrown out the Justice Department’s bid to block certification (DOJ says it will appeal), and prosecutors will not say what crime they are testing. The voters decide on November 3, before any of it is resolved.




